Zing. Its a reasonable list, but the author should have advised why HD DVD is still a good investment. If these are the reason not to go blu, let’s compare HD DVD facts and see who wins. read the list here

1. Nearly all current Blu-ray players are obsolete: The Blu-ray standard is still evolving. Most models currently available use the original Profile 1.0 standard, while some newer models use Profile 1.1 (which adds the ability to show picture-in-picture commentaries). Later this year, the first Profile 2.0 players–which add the ability to deliver online special features (BD Live)–will become available. Ironically, both of these are designed to bring the Blu-ray standard in line with HD DVD players, which have long been able to deliver these features.

A couple of the most recent Blu-ray players (the combo players from Samsung and LG) can be updated from Profile 1.0 to 1.1 with a downloadable firmware update. But the PlayStation 3 is, supposedly, the only existing Blu-ray player that will be fully upgradeable to Profile 2.0. So if you don’t want your Blu-ray player to be obsolete, the PS3 is your only choice until 2.0 models–such as the Panasonic DMP-BD50–hit later this year.

Caveat: Does anybody really watch those PiP-enabled commentaries? Or want updated trailers downloaded from the Web? Beyond the hardcore cinephiles, I think the answer is a big “no.” In other words, if you’re among the vast majority who only wants to watch the movie, you’re not really gaining anything with a 1.1. or 2.0 player. Those older Blu-ray players should play everything else on the disc (the non-playable features are just grayed out on the menu). With the older players hitting the discount racks to make way for newer models, getting a Profile 1.0 player is a nice way to score a Blu-ray player on the cheap ($300 or less).

If no one watched PIP features, DVD would have abandoned them, HD DVD would not have required 2 tuners as part of the format and Sony would not have built it into the Blu-ray standard Profile 2.0. Obviously there is a demand. Additionally, PIP features have been a part of HD DVD standard since Day 1. Advantage HD DVD. HD DVD 1 BD 0.

2. Blu-ray is best on a big-screen TV: Can you see the difference between standard DVD and Blu-ray? Yes–but it may not be as noticeable as you would think. Like all high-definition material, Blu-ray discs look their most-impressive at bigger screen sizes, where DVD can sometimes start to look a bit soft. Put another way: if your TV is 37 inches or smaller, you probably won’t be getting a huge advantage from Blu-ray.

Caveat: Eagle-eyed videophiles–or those who sit especially close to their 1080p TVs–may well see a difference. Rule of thumb: if HDTV programming looks noticeably better than DVD playback on your TV, then Blu-ray will be a worthwhile investment.

Of Course. Advantage: none. HD DVD 1 BD 0

3. There are still very few movies available on Blu-ray: As of February 5, 2008, there are less than 450 current Blu-ray titles available in North America (not counting discontinued and adult titles). That stacks up well to HD DVD (around 400). But it’s a drop in the bucket compared to standard DVD, which has at least 90,000 titles available (including TV shows).

Caveat: Sure, it’s small now, but the number of Blu-ray titles is growing slowly but surely. In fact, Blu-ray and HD DVD adoption (combined) has actually outpaced that of the original DVD format, which took three or four years before it really went mainstream.

Again, duh, and the same goes for HD DVD. Although everyone is counting HD DVD out, its not over until the fat lady sings. Obsolesence of a million $500 dollar players and a bunch of PS3 fan-boys keep HD DVD in the game. However, with the recent defection by Warner, Blu-ray has a bigger library (that’s what she said). Advantage: Blu-ray. HD DVD 1 BD 1

4. Blu-ray still has growing pains: How many times have you popped a brand new DVD into your player, only to be greeted with a message that you need to update the firmware to view the movie? Probably never, but Blu-ray early adopters have faced this message more than they would like to admit. (To be fair, HD DVD has had its share of disc compatibility issues as well.) To make matters worse, many early Blu-ray players can’t update via Ethernet, so you’ll need to burn a CD to update the player. If you’re reading Crave, burning a disc probably isn’t a problem–but there are many less-tech-savvy people that love DVDs, but have no idea what an ISO file is.

This point validates Blu-ray’s need for Profiles, something the author tried to downplay in point 2 … Blu-ray is incomplete. Unlike Blu-ray, HD DVD has no growing pains, It is a complete format. If Toshiba releases firmware updates – which they have in the past – installation is an option. You will either be able to use the built in ethernet port which is mandatory to the format (when wifi?) or burn a CD. All movies will play regardless of the firmware version. Advantage: HD DVD. HD DVD 2 BD 1.

5. Prices have nowhere to go but down: Even without competition from HD DVD, Blu-ray prices seem to be on a one-way ticket downward. Older players can be purchases for about $300, so don’t be surprised to see Black Friday 2008 specials at $249 or $199. Caveat: See item number 1: the cheaper players are likely to be older models that are effectively “obsolete.”

Of course. If this is a primer on whether or not to go Blu, and point 5 reflects the conventional wisdom, sales of BD players will not be strong enough in ‘08 to support the fall of HD DVD. HD DVD prices are already sub-$200. Advantage HD DVD. HD DVD 3 BD 1.

There is it, even factoring in studio support for Blu-ray, HD DVD still trumps.

Sphere: Related Content